Traditional gender roles have a negative impact,
especially on children. Traditional gender roles can absolutely make a child
believe the worst about themselves and their abilities; the subsequent stigmas
negatively affect a child’s psyche. Young children exposed to traditional
gender roles will be more likely to perpetuate them later in life. Everyone can
benefit from gender-neutral parenting. Some people totally miss the point of
gender neutral parenting and proceed to spread the wrong information.
Gender-neutral parenting is not trying to erase gender by being completely
against femininity or masculinity, does not alter your child’s sexuality, and
is not only for parenting trans* children. Children should be raised without
traditional gender roles and as gender-neutral as possible to allow them to
develop their own identity and ideas about gender and sexuality in general and
in regards to themselves.
Tuesday, November 18, 2014
OUTLINE draft
- Introduction: I define my topic briefly and state my thesis.
- Traditional gender roles have a negative impact on children.
- Traditional gender roles can absolutely make a child believe the worst about themselves and their abilities. (Jacobs & Eccles)
- Traditional gender roles and subsequent stigmas negatively affect a child’s psyche. (Halim et al)
- Young children exposed to traditional gender roles will be more likely to perpetuate them later in life. (Halim et al)
- Many parents perpetuate traditional gender roles, making it hard for children to create their own ideas about gender and their own gender. (Leaper)
- Gender-neutral parenting is extremely beneficial.
- GNP is not trying to erase gender by being completely against femininity or masculinity, does not alter your child’s sexuality, and is not only for parenting trans* children. (Lucas-Stannard)
- Some people totally miss the point of gender neutral parenting and proceed to spread the wrong information. (Villalva)
- People overreact to gender-neutral parenting when, in actuality, they do not understand. (Gibson)
- Children that are forced into their sex-type stereotypes have a harder time developing their own identity. (Knafo et al)
- Thesis statement: Children should be raised without traditional gender roles and as gender-neutral as possible to allow them to develop their own identity and ideas about gender and sexuality in general and in regards to themselves.
- Background: Traditional gender roles and sex-typing
- A child’s perception of self is developed by a combination of their sex, their sex-specific stereotypes, their teacher’s ability rating, and, most of all, their mother’s perception (which can be affected by their internalized misogyny) of them. (Jacobs & Eccles)
- A family with traditional gender roles is going to probably raise a child with more positive ideals about traditional gender roles. (McHale et al)
- The idea that men should be the head of the household and following traditional gender roles can be harmful for children and families. (Qualls)
- “Think Barbie saying “Math is Hard” and then ponder why so few women enter science, technology, engineering, and medicine. Think “boys don’t play with baby dolls” and then ponder why men don’t have the same skill level with newborns that women do”. (Lucas-Stannard)
- A lot of girls go through a “phase” of rejecting all things girly and embracing traditionally masculine images. (Halim et al)
- The older a child becomes, the more likely they were to participate in sex-typed activities. (Schuette & Killen)
- Children pick up on gender-relative negative connotations when boys get praised for being strong, smart leaders, girls are being praised for their good looks and manners. (Halim et al)
- school sexual education is lacking and is in need of a complete remodel, especially when it comes to gender and sexuality. (Pyne)
- Gender stereotypes greatly effected the psyche and ideals of people throughout their entire life. (Zucker)
- Impact: Gender identity and sexuality
- Gender binary classifies two separate sex/genders: ultra-feminine female and ultra-masculine male.
- From the very start, ideals about the separation of strict male and female genders are drilled into children’s heads.
- The traditional gender binary causes people to have expectations for gender.
- In ancient times, gender variations were not uncommon. (Chew)
- There are biological and cognitive factors in gender development differences. (McGraw-Hill)
- Gender differences in children raised by non-heterosexual couples are more accepted and understood. (Gato & Fontaine)
- There are a lot of negative stigmas around non-heterosexual couples adopting children. (Gato & Fontaine)
- “A child’s sexual orientation will be what it will be. Nothing a parent does will change that”. (Lucas-Stannard)
- People are starting to recognize that some people find themselves outside the gender binary.
- CJ is as an example of a child that falls outside the gender binary and should not have to conform or decide who, or even what, he is yet. (DiBlasi)
- More and more places have started offering an “other” option beside male and female, but many continue to not recognize other genders. (Chew)
- Without proper gender and sex education, children may believe they are “broken”, and that what they feel and who they are is incorrect. (Pyne)
- FOR: Gender-neutral parenting
- Raising children gender-neutrally can help children not feel so lost in their self-identification. (Pyne)
- Recently, many children are identifying as non-binary and/or non-heterosexual at a younger age. (DiBlasi)
- Some people have hard time labeling their gender and picking pronouns. (Chew)
- Non-binary genders and other related topics are becoming more universally recognized. (Chan)
- There are many factors that lead to gender identity issues in non-heterosexual youths. (Wood et al)
- Gender-neutral parenting is not a social experiment, but merely a way to expand what a child could and/or will become. (Lucas-Stannard)
- Weighing all the physical and social repercussions from GNP can take a long time. (Parents Magazine)
- Raising a child gender-neutrally can lead to questions from both parent and children who are not informed. (Parents Magazine)
- Many people have ideas about how children should be raised, even if it is not their children.
- Even when Sasha, a child raised with gender-neutral parenting, deemed traditional gender values stupid, a lot of people claimed that Laxton and Cooper’s parenting style was child abuse and brainwashing. (Gibson)
- Children like CJ (Trans*) would benefit from gender-neutral parenting. (DiBlasi)
- People overreact to GNP when, in actuality, they do not understand.
- Some people totally miss the point of gender neutral parenting and proceed to spread the wrong information. (Villalva)
- A family with traditional gender roles is going to probably raise a child with more positive ideals about traditional gender roles. [why this is bad, reference above points] (McHale et al)
- Conclusion: Gender-neutral parenting is the future. Gender-neutral parenting “expose[s] kids to a wide range of gender-types and give[s] them the freedom to explore without judgment those that call to them”. (Lucas-Stannard)
RATIONALE draft
I will define my topic (gender-neutral
parenting) and explain why I think this issue is important (the negative impact
of traditional gender roles). To further explain, I will make a few points
about how bad traditional gender roles are, especially for children (see
outline). Then, I will explain more
about gender-neutral parenting and the varying opinions on the matter. As I am
not an esteemed expert on this topic, I will reference some of the well-known
scholars I found in my research. I will paraphrase some of their research in
order to provide background and context on my subject. At the end of my
introduction, I will state my thesis in an obvious fashion so the themes I
write about will not seem foreign to the reader and clearly make this an
academic paper which will add to my credibility in this field.
Chapter 13
A paper with proper organization is a better paper, as chapter 13 of the Bedford Researcher explains. When a reader can expect what will happen next in your document, they will be more engaged and interested. Choosing an organization pattern is one step in organizing your document. The Bedford Researcher has 10 examples of different organization patterns. By comparing your topic to the different organization patterns, it is easy to see what is the best fit. Organizing your evidence with labels, groups, or clusters can help you stay focused and keep your ideas together. With all of your evidence coordinated, you can go on to create an outline: first informal, then formal.
The last section of chapter 13 is very useful for what we are doing in class right now. As we create our outlines for the final research paper, these tips and instructions are just what I need. Having examples of the transitions from informal to formal topical and sentence outlines is really nice to see. Being able to really connect how the different outlines help an author succeed in writing an actual draft of their paper is interesting and makes writing an outline easier for me.
The last section of chapter 13 is very useful for what we are doing in class right now. As we create our outlines for the final research paper, these tips and instructions are just what I need. Having examples of the transitions from informal to formal topical and sentence outlines is really nice to see. Being able to really connect how the different outlines help an author succeed in writing an actual draft of their paper is interesting and makes writing an outline easier for me.
Chapter 19
The Bedford Researcher's chapter 19 continues the design theme of chapter 18. Chapter 19 is a broader view of how to design big-picture documents and presentations, versus chapter 18's general design rules.
This chapter has instructions for designing academic essays, multimodal essays, articles, web sites, and oral, multimedia, or poster presentations. Many of the instructions for each type of document or presentation are similar. The Bedford Researcher suggests and author consider their purpose first and foremost for each document or presentation. The tips for documents tend to be almost identical, with some variations depending on the medium.
This chapter has instructions for designing academic essays, multimodal essays, articles, web sites, and oral, multimedia, or poster presentations. Many of the instructions for each type of document or presentation are similar. The Bedford Researcher suggests and author consider their purpose first and foremost for each document or presentation. The tips for documents tend to be almost identical, with some variations depending on the medium.
I will probably be able to utilize the information on design later in my life. Being able to create presentations that are both engaging and informative may help my end-goals. As my big-picture dream job is traveling to high schools talking about suicide prevention and good mental health, the subsections on oral, multimedia, and perhaps poster presentations will probably be useful. Even if I do not come back and reference this book when creating my presentations, the information I read is probably internalized and will help me create an interesting presentation that people can learn from.
Chapter 18
Chapter 18 of the Bedford Researcher is all about principles of design. Although we have been coached from childhood to "not judge a book by it's cover", it is an indisputable fact that design can sway how a person feels about something. A badly designed paper can create unsettled or even negative connotations in the reader, leading them to associate the topic with bad feelings. This is something no writer wants to happen. Using the top five principles of design, an author can create an aesthetically-pleasing paper so the reader can focus on the information. Balance, emphasis, placement, repetition, and consistency can help an author "accomplish [their] goals" (286). Different designs can convey different ideals. When considering a design for your paper, it is important to decide your goals. Are you designing for a purpose? Or for your readers? Or are you designing to address genre conventions? These are questions an author must answer before creating their paper's aesthetic.
The subsection on design elements of this chapter is very informative. This chapter explains how to further support your argument through design elements. Design elements are options like fonts, line spacing, alignment, layouts, color, shading, borders, and illustrations. This chapter's information on illustrations can be applied to my work on my research paper. By explaining how to use illustrations, the Bedford Researcher helps implementing more design elements into my paper easier.
The subsection on design elements of this chapter is very informative. This chapter explains how to further support your argument through design elements. Design elements are options like fonts, line spacing, alignment, layouts, color, shading, borders, and illustrations. This chapter's information on illustrations can be applied to my work on my research paper. By explaining how to use illustrations, the Bedford Researcher helps implementing more design elements into my paper easier.
Chapter 12
It is pretty obvious that a well-developed argument is essential in any research paper. Chapter 12 contains instructions on how to support your thesis statement with an accurate and unquestionable argument. Your "effective argument" is more of a game plan then just producing information about your topic. Using good reasons, authentic evidence, and authoritative appeal can construct an argument that boosts your thesis to make you, as an author, seem more legitimate. An argument can and should appeal to different parts or feelings people have. Arguments can appeal to authority, emotion, values, character, and/or logic. A well-made argument with integrity without fallacies is the best type.
A thesis statement is not as powerful without a strong, backing argument. An important part of an argument is ensuring it does not contain any fallacies. This chapter helps an author sift through their argument for questionable assumptions, misrepresentation, and careless reasoning. Some of the sources with a negative view of GNP I found in my research have fallacies based on these three categories. Even though the information may not be accurate, people can spread allegedly bad news and incorrect information through the power of assumption. This chapter can help me prove the negative articles wrong.
A thesis statement is not as powerful without a strong, backing argument. An important part of an argument is ensuring it does not contain any fallacies. This chapter helps an author sift through their argument for questionable assumptions, misrepresentation, and careless reasoning. Some of the sources with a negative view of GNP I found in my research have fallacies based on these three categories. Even though the information may not be accurate, people can spread allegedly bad news and incorrect information through the power of assumption. This chapter can help me prove the negative articles wrong.
Chapter 11
Instructions for developing a thesis statement are found in chapter 11 of the Bedford Researcher. Thesis statements can be tricky and hard to create. It is important to continually reference your position and review your notes to find the right information and ideas you want to express in your thesis statement. Your thesis can be taken from a research question, feedback on sources, and an evaluation of any research done. The Bedford Researcher explains that a thesis statement is "the most important idea or argument you want to convey" (203) in your paper. Many authors have various drafts of their thesis statement before they decide on the best, most focused version.
This chapter explains how to make the best thesis statement for your topic. If a thesis statement is too broad, it does not do its job properly because it cannot be argued. Being able to draft your thesis by considering all aspects of your topic and project with this chapter is really nice to have. Your thesis statement essentially sets the tone for the whole paper. A weak, badly constructed thesis can make a reader feel negatively about your topic before they have even read your whole paper.
This chapter explains how to make the best thesis statement for your topic. If a thesis statement is too broad, it does not do its job properly because it cannot be argued. Being able to draft your thesis by considering all aspects of your topic and project with this chapter is really nice to have. Your thesis statement essentially sets the tone for the whole paper. A weak, badly constructed thesis can make a reader feel negatively about your topic before they have even read your whole paper.
Chapter 16
Chapter 16 of the Bedford Researcher instructs writers on how to "write with style". This chapter includes instructions on how to keep your writing concise and how to consistently keep a point of view using active/passive voice correctly. There are many words and phrases authors should learn to avoid. Unnecessary modifiers and introductory phrases such as "really" or "very fine" and "there is" or "here are" clog up sentences and should be eliminated, a long with stock phrases. Too many words in a sentence may make an author feel more professional, but can just confuse the reader and could even change the sentence's meaning. Using passive and active voice can provide emphasis, but if used wrong or combined can make the author seem uneducated. This chapter also helps an author carefully choose their words to framing your argument. Distinguishing when it is appropriate to use formal language versus more casual or specialized language can help polish the written work.
This chapter's section on transitions is very useful. Transitions can make all of the difference in a paper, and having a lot of transitional words displayed and explained is useful in the writing process. As it is expected to reference other authors or scholars in my research paper, the subsection with examples on creatively introducing other authors will be very handy. A paper full of boring transitions or even no transitions is not a good paper.
This chapter's section on transitions is very useful. Transitions can make all of the difference in a paper, and having a lot of transitional words displayed and explained is useful in the writing process. As it is expected to reference other authors or scholars in my research paper, the subsection with examples on creatively introducing other authors will be very handy. A paper full of boring transitions or even no transitions is not a good paper.
Thursday, November 13, 2014
Lit Review
Raising Children
Gender-Neutral: The Parenting Style of the Future
Traditional
gender roles have a negative impact, especially on children. Traditional gender
roles include stereotypes like a breadwinning father and a homemaking mother.
These sex-based stereotypes can prevent a child from establishing their own
gender identity, sexuality, and sense of self. Traditional gender roles are
perpetuated by religion, stereotypes, and misogyny (internalized or otherwise).
Gender-neutral parenting (GNP) is the best way to raise children without the
negative side effects of traditional gender roles. Gender-neutral parenting
means avoiding raising a child either androgynously (completely without gender)
or in a strict gender binary (sex and gender as only two completely separate
forms of masculine males and feminine females). Some people believe that
raising children gender neutrally can be harmful to the child and is simply
forcefully pressing the parents’ beliefs on a young, impressionable future
voter. This, however, is untrue. Children should be raised without traditional
gender roles and as gender-neutral as possible to allow them to develop their
own identity and ideas about gender and sexuality in general and in regards to
themselves. Most articles I found and utilized in my research falls under three
basic subjects: gender-neutral parenting, traditional gender roles and
sex-typing, and gender identity and sexuality.
Gender-neutral
parenting is the best way to allow a child to develop their own perceptions of
self. Gender-Neutral parenting is a very controversial topic with a lot of
wrong information out in the world. Paige Lucas-Stannard wrote "5 Myths
About Gender Neutral Parenting” on EverydayFeminism.com
in 2013 and introduces what gender-neutral parenting (GNP) actually is and
attempts to clear up a few misconceptions. Lucas-Stannard explains that GNP is
not trying to erase gender by being completely against femininity or
masculinity, does not alter your child’s sexuality, and is not only for
parenting trans* children. Lucas-Stannard clarifies that GNP is not a social
experiment, but merely a way to expand what a child could and/or will become.
Brittney R. Villalva has a very negative view on GNP that she wrote about in
her article "Gender Liberation: The Harmful Effects of Raising Children
'Gender Neutral'" on ChristianPost.com.
Her points are completely discredited by the aforementioned Everyday Feminism
source. Villalva claims that GNP is a political statement that is harmful for
children. This source to show how some people totally miss the point of gender
neutral parenting and proceed to spread the wrong information.
Many
people have ideas about how children should be raised, even if it is not their
children. Megan Gibson wrote "Parents Who Hid Child's Gender for Five
Years Now Face Backlash” in a 2012 issue of Time Magazine.
Beck Laxton and Kieran Cooper decided to not reveal their child Sasha’s gender
to the world after he was born. Sasha was encouraged to play with all sorts of
dolls and toys and wore whatever clothes he wanted to. After Sasha entered
school, his parents decided it would be too difficult to keep his gender a
secret. Many people and the media took interest in Sasha’s gender-neutral
upbringing. Even though Sasha himself deemed traditional gender values stupid,
a lot of people claimed that Laxton and Cooper’s GNP was child abuse and
brainwashing. People overreact to GNP when, in actuality, they do not
understand. It’s important that anyone, even people without children, educate
themselves on various parenting styles including GNP. Parents Magazine
published "Should You Raise a Gender-neutral Baby?" because deciding
how to raise your child can be a tough decision. Weighing all the physical and
social repercussions from GNP can take a long time. This article outlines most
of the arguments around GNP. Raising a child gender-neutrally can lead to
questions from both parent and children who are not informed. This article will
be useful in showing both sides of the GNP discussion because it provides insight
on many factors of GNP.
From
the very start, ideals about the separation of strict male and female genders
are drilled into children’s heads. Susan D. Witt wrote about traditional gender
roles and what this means to children as they are developing in her article
"Parental Influence on Children's Socialization to Gender Roles” published
by Caly Poly College of Liberal Arts. Witt discusses how parents impact a
child’s self-concept and how gender-neutral parenting is beneficial. However,
Witt does call it androgynous parenting, which is not quite right. Janis E.
Jacobs and Jacquelynne S. Eccles also wrote about children’s perception of self
in "The Impact of Mothers' Gender-Role Stereotypic Beliefs on Mothers' and
Children's Ability Perceptions" published in The
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in 1992 by the
Research Center for Group Dynamics. The authors explain what factors create a
child’s “perception of self”. A child’s mother has a very large influence on
children’s thought about the world and themselves. Although their mother, and
the mother’s internalized misogyny, is the most significant factor, a child’s
sex, sex-related stereotypes, and a teacher’s ability rating all combine and
effect how a child thinks of themselves and what they can do. Traditional
gender roles can absolutely make a child believe the worst about themselves and
their abilities. Campbell Leaper wrote “Parents’ Socialization of Gender in
Children” in The Encyclopedia on Early Childhood Education
in
2013 because A child’s gender may not match the sex and therefore gender they
were assigned at birth. Campbell Leaper writes about families’ and especially
parents’ effect on a child’s perception of their gender. Many parents
perpetuate traditional gender roles, making it hard for children to create
their own ideas about gender and their own gender. Home life and parents’
differential treatment of their children does have an impact on their gender
development.
Even
children are aware of the gender-based stereotypes and stigmas, as May Ling
Halim and colleagues wrote in "Pink Frilly Dresses and the Avoidance of
All Things ‘Girly’: Children's Appearance Rigidity and Cognitive Theories of
Gender Development" published in The Social and
Personality Psychology Compass in 2011. A lot of girls go through
a “phase” of rejecting all things girly and embracing traditionally masculine
images. The authors of this article discuss why this happens as children enter
school. When boys get praised for being strong, smart leaders, girls are being praised
for their good looks and manners. After seeing “tough” boys getting respect and
“girly” girls being treated as trophies by adults, children pick up on these
negative conceptions about their own genders. The authors show that traditional
gender roles and subsequent stigmas negatively affect a child’s psyche. Young
children exposed to traditional gender roles will be more likely to perpetuate
them later in life. Ariel Knafo and colleagues wrote about sex-typing in
"Masculine Girls and Feminine Boys: Genetic and Environmental
Contributions to Atypical Gender Development in Early Childhood" published
in The
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in 2005. These authors
studied children participating in sex-typed activities and how parent-encourage
sex type actives are harmful to children. This article will be helpful in
showing that children that are thrust into their traditional gender roles have
a harder time developing their own identity.
Susan
M. McHale and colleagues wrote on the same thread in "The Family Contexts
of Gender Intensification in Childhood and Adolescence", published in Social
Development in 2003. Boys and girls develop differently at
adolescence. The authors of this article were curious if gender stereotypes and
sex-role attitudes had any effect of this development. The authors found that
family had the most impact of children’s development, which makes sense. A
family with traditional gender roles is going to probably raise a child with
more positive ideals about traditional gender roles. Families that perpetuate
traditional gender roles negatively impact their child’s gender development. A
lot of families rely on traditional gender roles for decision making. As
William Qualls writes in "Changing Sex Roles: Its Impact Upon Family Decision
Making" as published by The Association for Consumer
Research
in 1982, the idea that men should be the head of the household and following
traditional gender roles can be harmful for children and families. Qualls looks
further into what traditional gender roles means and what following them for
decisions can do. Christine Schuette and Melanie Killen write about the impact
of traditional gender roles on children at different times in their lives in
"Children's Evaluations of Gender-Stereotypic Household Activities in the
Family Context" published in Early Education
& Development in 2009 by the University of Maryland.
As children become older, their ideas about gender change. The authors looked at three different ages:
five, eight, and ten. Their research showed that the older a child became, the
more likely they were to participate in sex-typed activities.
Recently,
many children are identifying as non-binary and/or non-heterosexual at a
younger age. Loren DiBlasi wrote about a couple raising a child, CJ, who they
deemed “gender creative” in "Gender Creative Boy C.J. & Gender
Non-Conforming Vs. Transgender" published by Recapo
RSS.
Though CJ identifies as the sex he was assigned at birth, he prefers
traditionally feminine activities and dress. Though GNP is not discussed in
this article, it seems that CJ would benefit from a more gender-neutral
environment. CJ is as an example of a child that falls outside the gender
binary and should not have to conform or decide who, or even what, he is yet.
The traditional gender binary causes people to have expectations for gender.
The author of "Gender Roles and Gender Differences” published in Gender
Roles and Gender Differences by McGraw-Hill Higher Education
outlines some of these standards and explains how these negatively affect a
child. The author also describes biological and cognitive factors in gender
development differences. The scientific definitions of non-binary “behavior” is
useful in explaining what non-binary vs binary actually is.
Kristina
Chew highlights the road blocks people are facing through their identifications
in “Ze, Hir, Hirs; He, She, They: Which Pronouns Are You?" published by Care2.
. One large problem is pronouns. More and more places have started offering an
“other” option beside male and female, but many continue to not recognize other
genders. Some people have hard time labeling their gender, and therefore have
trouble picking their preferred pronouns. Chew also writes about ancient
societies genders in stories, noting that gender variations were not uncommon.
This source will probably not be useful, unless I write about how traditional
gender roles can make non-binary children more comfortable. GrammarMudge
also
published an article about prounouns, entitled “The Great Pronoun Debate: An
Attempt to Resolve a Touchy Issue”. Pronouns are a touchy subject, especially
for people who do not understand the gender spectrum. This article outlines
where pronoun differences come in and some historical information on pronouns.
There is a lot of debate about using “they” as a singular pronoun, which is
what some people prefer instead of “he” “she” or “ze”. This article explains
why making singular “they” grammatically correct would be a good idea. Earlier
in my process I had planned to focus on gender roles rather than GNP, so with
my changed focus these sources are not as useful. People are starting to
recognize that some people find themselves outside the gender binary. Gender
binary classifies two separate sex/genders: ultra-feminine female and ultra-masculine
male Amanda Chan writes "Gender Dysphoria: DSM-5 Reflects Shift In
Perspective On Gender Identity" for The Huffington
Post
in 2013 about the definition of gender dysphoria found the newest edition of
the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (the DSM), the most
referenced and recognized mental health manual. People are starting to
recognize that some people find themselves outside the gender binary. Gender
binary classifies two separate sex/genders: ultra-feminine female and ultra-masculine
male. The DSM-5 recognizes gender
dysphoria as distress rather than just an issue with identity. This source
shows that non-binary genders and other related topics are becoming more
universally recognized.
Hayley
Wood and colleagues wrote about their research on correlations with gender
dysphoria and sexuality in "Patterns of Referral to a Gender Identity
Service for Children and Adolescents (1976-2011): Age, Sex Ratio, and Sexual
Orientation”. These authors did a study and subsequently wrote about the
factors that lead to gender identity issues in non-heterosexual youths. In
recent times, it seems that many non-heterosexual youths with gender dysphoria
also have an autism spectrum disorder. The authors note that even 10 years ago,
this would have been a strange thing to see. This article provides context for
gender dysphoria and other issues that non-heterosexual non-binary youths face.
Jorge Gato and Anne Marie Fontaine also wrote about non-heterosexual couples’
children in "Anticipation of the Sexual and Gender Development of Children
Adopted by Same-Sex Couples" published in The
International Journal of Psychology. There are a lot of
negative stigmas around non-heterosexual couples adopting children. Some “fear”
that non-heterosexual couples will “make” their children prefer other genders
than the opposite gender. However, this is a baseless claim. Jorge Gato and
Anne Marie Fontaine write about how non-heterosexual parents are really not
very different than heterosexual parents.
However, gender differences in children raised by non-heterosexual
couples is more accepted and understood.
There
are many studies done on the impact of gender roles on gender identity. Kenneth
Zucker and colleagues wrote about their questionnaire in "The Recalled Childhood Gender
Identity/Gender Role Questionnaire: Psychometric Properties" published in Sex
Roles
in 2006. The authors of this questionnaire asked over 200 people 23 questions.
The authors found that gender stereotypes greatly effected the psyche and ideals
of people throughout their entire life. This questionnaire is hard evidence
showing sex-related stereotypes and the effect on children’s development of
their thoughts. Jake Pyne writes in his article "Gender Independent Kids:
A Paradigm Shift in Approaches to Gender Non-conforming Children"
published in The Canadian Journal of Human Sexuality
in 2014 that school sexual education is lacking and is in need of a complete
remodel, especially when it comes to gender and sexuality. Pyne writes how
important it is for gender fluid, non-binary, or transgender children to
understand about themselves. Without proper gender and sex education, children
may believe they are “broken”, and that what they feel and who they are is
incorrect.
Raising
children gender-neutrally can help children not feel so lost in their
self-identification. Parents that do not conform to traditional gender roles
will most likely be more open to their children, no matter their gender or
sexuality. That being said, raising a child gender may not be easy. By making
the decision to remove traditional gender roles in a society where gender is
usually clearly separate, parents utilizing GNP ideals could potentially face a
lot of backlash. Children raised gender-neutral may face extreme negativity
from their peers that do not understand and were possibly raised with contrary
ideals. However, the positive impact of gender-neutral parenting far outweighs any
negative reactions the parent(s) and child may face.
Tuesday, November 4, 2014
Annotated Bibliography
Works Cited
Lucas-Stannard,
Paige. "5 Myths About Gender Neutral Parenting." Everyday
Feminism. Everyday Feminism.. Web.
14 Oct. 2014.
<http://everydayfeminism.com/2013/01/gender-neutral-parenting-myths/>.
Gender-Neutral
parenting is a very controversial topic with a lot of wrong information. Paige
Lucas-Stannard introduces what gender-neutral parenting (GNP) actually is and
then clears up a few misconceptions. Lucas-Stannard explains that GNP is not
trying to erase gender by being completely against femininity or masculinity,
does not alter your child’s sexuality, and is not only for parenting trans*
children. Lucas-Stannard finishes the article by clarifying that GNP is not a
social experiment, but merely a way to expand what a child could and/or will become.
I will use this source to attempt clear up some wrong assumptions about GNP.
Chew,
Kristina. "Ze, Hir, Hirs; He, She, They: Which Pronouns Are You?"
Care2. Care2.
Web.
11 Oct. 2014.
<http://www.care2.com/causes/ze-hir-hirs-he-she-they-which-pronoun-are-you.html?page=1>.
People are identifying
as genders outside of the gender binary (only two strict genders). Kristina
Chew highlights the road blocks people are facing through their
identifications. One large problem is pronouns. More and more places have started
offering an “other” option beside male and female, but many continue to not
recognize other genders. Some people have hard time labeling their gender, and
therefore have trouble picking their preferred pronouns. Chew also writes about
ancient societies genders in stories, noting that gender variations were not
uncommon. This source will probably not be useful, unless I write about how
traditional gender roles can make non-binary children more comfortable. Earlier
in my process I had planned to focus on gender roles rather than GNP, so with
my changed focus this article is not as useful.
Gato,
Jorge, and Anne Marie Fontaine. "Anticipation of the Sexual and Gender
Development of Children Adopted by Same-Sex Couples." International
Journal of Psychology 48.3 (2013): 244-53. Ebsco.
Web. 14 Oct. 2014.
<http://ezproxy.olympic.edu:2255/ehost/detail/detail?sid=e2749f4f-7f05-4aa6-beb3-97ff44c5580b%40sessionmgr4001&vid=0&hid=4212&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ%3d%3d#db=aph&AN=89102291>.
There are a lot of
negative stigmas around non-heterosexual couples adopting children. Some “fear”
that non-heterosexual couples will “make” their children prefer other genders
than the opposite gender. However, this is a baseless claim. Jorge Gato and
Anne Marie Fontaine write about how non-heterosexual parents are really not
very different than heterosexual parents.
However, gender differences in children raised by non-heterosexual
couples is more accepted and understood. I will use this source to explain that
non-heterosexual couples are actually superior (for lack of a better term) in
raising their children with less normative views of gender and sexuality.
DiBlasi,
Loren. "Gender Creative Boy C.J. & Gender Non-Conforming Vs.
Transgender." Recapo RSS. Recapo.
Web. 14 Oct. 2014.
<http://www.recapo.com/the-doctors/the-doctors-kids/gender-creative-boy-c-j-gender-non-conforming-vs-transgender/>.
Recently, many children
are identifying as non-binary at a younger age. Loren DiBlasi writes about a
couple raising a child, CJ, they deemed “gender creative”. Though CJ identifies
as the sex he was assigned at birth, he prefers traditionally feminine
activities and dress. Though GNP is not discussed in this article, it seems
that CJ would benefit from a more gender-neutral environment. I will use CJ as
an example of a child that falls outside the gender binary and should not have
to conform or decide who, or even what, he is yet.
Villalva,
Brittney R. "Gender Liberation: The Harmful Effects of Raising Children
'Gender Neutral'" Christian Post. Christian Post. Web.
14 Oct. 2014.
<http://www.christianpost.com/news/gender-liberation-the-harmful-effects-of-raising-children-gender-neutral-68134/>.
Some people have very
negative views on GNP. Brittney R Villalva has a very strong, anti-GNP stance.
She writes points that the aforementioned source by Everyday
Feminism
completely discredits. Villalva claims that GNP is a political statement that
is harmful for children. I will use this source to show how some people totally
miss the point of gender neutral parenting and proceed to spread the wrong
information.
Gender Neutral Bathroom Sign. Digital
image. Liberty News. Web. 27 Oct. 2014. <http:// www.libertynews.com/2013/04/word-police-throw-the-statute-book-at-gender-bias/>.
This is a picture within an article I am
probably going to use on my cover page. It looks like a bathroom sign, with one
person with half of the traditional female image basically copy/pasted next to
the traditional male image.
"Gender
Roles and Gender Differences." Gender Roles and
Gender Differences. McGraw-Hill Higher Education. Web. 11
Oct. 2014. <http://highered.mheducation.com/sites/0072820144/student_view0/chapter15/index.html>.
Within the traditional
gender binary, there are various stereotypes and expectations. The author of
this source outlines some of these standards and explains how these negatively
affect a child. The author also describes biological and cognitive factors in
gender development differences. Having this source, with the scientific
definitions of non-binary “behavior” will be useful in explaining what non-binary
vs binary actually is.
Gibson,
Megan. "Parents Who Hid Child's Gender for Five Years Now Face
Backlash." Time Magazine, 24 Jan. 2012. Time
Magazine. Web. 12 Oct. 2014.
<http://newsfeed.time.com/2012/01/24/parents-who-hid-childs-gender-for-five-years-now-face-backlash/>.
Many people have ideas about how children
should be raised, even if it is not their children. Beck Laxton and Kieran
Cooper decided to not reveal their child Sasha’s gender to the world after he
was born. Sasha was encouraged to play with all sorts of dolls and toys and
wore whatever clothes he wanted to. After Sasha entered school, his parents
decided it would be too difficult to keep his gender a secret. Many people and
the media took interest in Sasha’s gender-neutral upbringing. Even though Sasha
himself deemed traditional gender values stupid, a lot of people claimed that
Laxton and Cooper’s GNP was child abuse and brainwashing. I will use this
source to show how people overreact to GNP when, in actuality, they do not
understand.
"The
Great Pronoun Debate: An Attempt to Resolve a Touchy Issue." GrammarMudge.
Web.
14 Oct. 2014.
<http://www.grammarmudge.cityslide.com/articles/article/307084/22324.htm>.
Pronouns are a touchy
subject, especially for people who do not understand the gender spectrum. This
article outlines where pronoun differences come in and some historical
information on pronouns. There is a lot of debate about using “they” as a
singular pronoun, which is what some people prefer instead of “he” “she” or
“ze”. This article explains why making singular “they” grammatically correct
would be a good idea. This article is similar to the Care2
article, in that I probably will not reference it. The information is very
interesting, however.
Halim,
May Ling, et al. "Pink Frilly Dresses and the Avoidance of All Things
"Girly": Children's Appearance Rigidity and Cognitive Theories of
Gender Development." Social and Personality
Psychology Compass 5/11 (2011): 933–949. Amodio
Lab. Web.
03 Oct. 2014. <http://amodiolab.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/Halim-Ruble-Amodio-2011.pdf>.
Even children are aware of the gender-based
stereotypes and stigmas. A lot of girls go through a “phase” of rejecting all
things girly and embracing traditionally masculine images. The authors of this
article discuss why this happens as children enter school. When boys get
praised for being strong, smart leaders, girls are being praised for their good
looks and manners. After seeing “tough” boys getting respect and “girly” girls
being treated as trophies by adults, children pick up on these negative
conceptions about their own genders. This article will be very useful in
explaining how traditional gender roles negatively affect a child’s psyche.
Jacobs,
Janis E., and Jacquelynne S. Eccles. "The Impact of Mothers' Gender-Role
Stereotypic Beliefs on Mothers' and Children's Ability Perceptions." Journal
of Personality and Social Psychology 63.6 (1992): 932-44. Research
Center for Group Dynamics. University of Michigan. Web. 02
Oct. 2014. <http://www.rcgd.isr.umich.edu/garp/articles/jacobs92.pdf>.
A child’s mother has a
very large influence on children’s thought about the world and themselves. The
authors of this article explain what factors create a child’s “perception of
self”. Although their mother, and the mother’s internalized misogyny, is the
most significant factor, a child’s sex, sex-related stereotypes, and a
teacher’s ability rating all combine and effect how a child thinks of
themselves and what they can do. This article will be vital in showing how
traditional gender roles can absolutely make a child believe the worst about
themselves and their abilities.
Knafo,
Ariel, Alessandra C. Lervolino, and Robert Plomin. "Masculine Girls and
Feminine Boys: Genetic and Environmental Contributions to Atypical Gender
Development in Early Childhood." Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology 88.2 (2005): 400-12. Ebsco.
Web.
07 Oct. 2014. <http://ezproxy.olympic.edu:2257/ehost/detail/detail?sid=7e57c164-885d-410b-bb73-fb11fcd86c15%40sessionmgr114&vid=0&hid=116&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ%3d%3d#db=aph&AN=15956992>.
Young children exposed
to traditional gender roles will be more likely to perpetuate them later in
life. These authors studied children participating in sex-typed activities and
how parent-encourage sex type actives are harmful to children. This article
will be helpful in showing that children that are thrust into their traditional
gender roles have a harder time developing their own identity.
Leaper,
Campbell. "Parents' Socialization of Gender in Children."
Encyclopedia on Early Childhood Education (2013). Ebsco.
Web.
02 Oct. 2014.
<http://www.child-encyclopedia.com/documents/LeaperANGxp1.pdf>.
A child’s gender may not
match the sex and therefore gender they were assigned at birth. Campbell Leaper
writes about families’ and especially parents’ effect on a child’s perception
of their gender. Many parents perpetuate traditional gender roles, making it
hard for children to create their own ideas about gender and their own gender.
Home life and parents’ differential treatment of their children does have an
impact on their gender development. This article is useful because it shows not
only parents’, but also how siblings and parents’ treatment of
different-gendered siblings impacts children’s gender development.
McHale,
Susan M., Ann C. Crouter, and Shawn D. Whiteman. "The Family Contexts of
Gender Intensification in Childhood and Adolescence." Social
Development 12.1 (2003): 125-48. Sanchez
Lab. Web.
08 Oct. 2014. <http://www.sanchezlab.com/pdfs/familycontext.pdf>.
Boys and girls develop
differently at adolescence. The authors of this article were curious if gender
stereotypes and sex-role attitudes had any effect of this development. The
authors found that family had the most impact of children’s development, which
makes sense. A family with traditional gender roles is going to probably raise
a child with more positive ideals about traditional gender roles. This article
will be handy in supporting how negative traditional gender roles are and how
families that perpetuate gender roles negatively impact their child’s gender
development.
Pyne,
Jake. "Gender Independent Kids: A Paradigm Shift in Approaches to Gender
Non-conforming Children." Canadian Journal of Human
Sexuality 23.1 (2014): 1-8. Ebsco. Web.
03 Oct. 2014.
<http://ezproxy.olympic.edu:2255/ehost/detail/detail?sid=cf80e7b4-6219-4651-8d31-7afc3e693d35%40sessionmgr4002&vid=0&hid=4109&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ%3d%3d#db=aph&AN=95572517>.
Children are being
raised with incorrect understandings of gender. Jake Pyne writes that it is
becoming increasingly more important to understand children who do not fit the
traditional male or female gender. School sexual education is lacking and is in
need of a complete remodel, especially when it comes to gender and sexuality.
Pyne writes how important it is for gender fluid, non-binary, or transgender
children to understand about themselves. This article will be useful in
providing ideas for how to conduct gender-neutral teaching (in sexual education
classes) to support gender-neutral parenting.
Qualls,
William J. "Changing Sex Roles: Its Impact Upon Family Decision
Making." Association for Consumer Research (1982):
267-70.
NA-
Advances in Consumer Research. 14 Oct. 2014. Ebsco. <http://www.acrwebsite.org/search/view-conference-proceedings.aspx?Id=6006>.
A lot of families rely
on traditional gender roles for decision making. As William Qualls writes, the
idea that men should be the head of the household and following traditional
gender roles can be harmful for children and families. Qualls looks further
into what traditional gender roles means and what following them for decisions
can do. This article will be useful in further explaining what traditional
gender roles are and why they are a bad thing.
"Should
You Raise a Gender-neutral Baby?" Parents Magazine. Parents
Magazine
Web. 14 Oct. 2014. <http://www.parents.com/parenting/gender-neutral-parenting/>.
Deciding how to raise
your child can be a tough decision. Weighing all the physical and social
repercussions from GNP can take a long time. This article outlines most of the
arguments around GNP. Raising a child gender-neutrally can lead to questions
from both parent and children who are not informed. This article will be useful
in showing both sides of the GNP discussion because it provides insight on many
factors of GNP.
Witt,
Susan D. "Parental Influence on Children's Socialization to Gender
Roles." Caly Poly College of Liberal Arts. Web. 04 Oct. 2014.
<http://cla.calpoly.edu/~bmori/syll/311syll/Witt.html>.
From the very start,
ideals about the separation of strict male and female genders are drilled into
children’s heads. Susan Witt writes about traditional gender roles and what
this means to children as they are developing. Witt discusses how parents
impact a child’s self-concept and how gender-neutral parenting is beneficial.
However, Witt does call it androgynous parenting, which is not quite right.
This source will be useful by supporting Janis Jacobs’ and Jacquelynne Eccles’
research.
Wood,
Hayley, Shoko Sasaki, Susan J. Bradley, Devita Singh, Sophia Fantus, Allison
Owen-Anderson, Jerald Di Giacomo, Kenneth J. Bain, and Kenneth J. Zucker.
"Patterns of Referral to a Gender Identity Service for Children and Adolescents
(1976-2011): Age, Sex Ratio, and Sexual Orientation.". Web. 05 Oct. 2014. Ebsco.
<http://ezproxy.olympic.edu:2257/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?sid=67c8f207-58ab-4986-94f4-c321c08e51b1%40sessionmgr111&vid=2&hid=116>.
There is science and
research done on correlations with
gender dysphoria and sexuality. These authors did a study and
subsequently wrote about the factors that lead to gender identity issues in
non-heterosexual youths. In recent times, it seems that many non-heterosexual
youths with gender dysphoria also have
an autism spectrum disorder. The authors note that even 10 years ago, this
would have been a strange thing to see. This article will be useful in
providing context for gender dysphoria and other issues that non-heterosexual
non-binary youths face.
Zucker,
Kenneth, Janet N. Mitchell, Susan J. Bradley, Jan Tkachuk, James M. Cantor, and
Sara M. Allin. "The Recalled Childhood Gender Identity/Gender Role
Questionnaire: Psychometric Properties." Sex Roles 54.7/8 (2006): 469-83.
Ebsco. Web. 07 Oct. 2014. <http://ezproxy.olympic.edu:2067/docview/225372877?accountid=2203>.
There are many studies
done on the impact of gender roles on gender identity. The authors of this questionnaire
asked over 200 people 23 questions. The authors found that gender stereotypes
greatly effected the psyche and ideals of people throughout their entire life.
This questionnaire will be useful in showing hard evidence about sex-related
stereotypes and the effect of children’s development of their thoughts.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)